You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

0
0

[–] cyclops1771 ago 

That's what I was saying - Samuel Untermayer was the head of the Non-Secular Anti-Nazi League. He teamed with a few Jewish groups in 1933 to start the anti-Germany boycotts.

Second, this statement is hilarious, "These zionists stopped deprtations, therefore, causing Jews to be imprisoned in concentration camps." Yes, because those were the ONLY two options. This is called the False dichotomy logical fallacy. "Deportation or imprisonment." No, they could have assimilated. they could have renounced their faith. They could have been moved and spread out so they couldn't congregate in one place, thereby reducing their effectiveness. They could have, you know, NOT been imprisoned in the first place? No blame at all on the people who did the imprisonment of a person based on their religion or ethnicity. It's all on the "international zionist" for their imprisonment. "You MADE me do this, you know!" To me, this is laughable.

No, there was never a plan to call anything Judea. Judea already existed as an area of Palestine. When the Jews took over Palestine in 1948, they used the name Israel. There were hisotircally 2 Kingdoms of Jews - The Kingdom of Israel, and the Kingdom of Judah. These were united (possibly) during the reigns of King David and Solomon. Judea is the ROMAN name of the province that contained these former Kingdoms. The Zionists were trying to recreate their ancient kingdom - so would have used Israel or Judah - not recreate the Roman province, so would not have used the term "Judea" for any logical reason.

They mentioned the Madagascar plan - the Zionists refused this, as well as carving out other areas of the world for their Jew country, demanding their "ancestral homeland, given to them by GOD" as the only option. And yet, this film also claimed that deportations stopped - but they DID work out a Transfer deal, which allowed migrating Jews to go from Germany to Palestine and keep much more of their wealth - in the form of buying German goods, having them exported to Palestine, and then re-sold there to get your money back. This actually helped spur German economic growth in the 1930's - these Jews left Germany, converted their wealth into German manufactures, and then exported to Palestine. Win-Win for the German government -- you get rid of undesirables and deplorables, AND you get an economic boost when they leave.

Civic groups cannot "declare war". They called for a boycott. If I decide to boycott Israel-owned businesses, am I "declaring war" on Israel? No. I am choosing not to provide capital to Israeli businesses.