You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

0
0

[–] the_sovereign ago 

Ok now we are arguing in circles. I showed you where in the book it says that Jews should be subjected to poison gas. You said it was a WW1 metaphor. Perhaps it was, but sadly, Jews were gassed in concentration camps such as Auschwitz. The perpetrators of these atrocities were the primary readers of the book and their leader was the author. There's your cause-and-effect. Simple enough?

0
0

[–] MasivGam3 ago  (edited ago)

I showed you where in the book it says that Jews should be subjected to poison gas.

You showed me where in the book it said that had those war profiteers died of poison gas instead of the honest people that actually did, the world would perhaps be a better place. And, you know what - tada! - those profiteers just happened to be Jews. Some call for genocide indeed.

You said it was a WW1 metaphor.

I did not say it was a metaphor. Metaphor is something else.

Perhaps it was, but sadly, Jews were gassed in concentration camps such as Auschwitz.

It is believed that some were.

The perpetrators of these atrocities were the primary readers of the book and their leader was the author.

I am sure most of those perpetrators never ever even read the book. Perpetrators of those atrocities also were riding bicycles and eating cabbages. Which proves that riding bicycles and eating cabbages leads to genocide. Also the author spoke a lot about other subjects too, like personal hygiene. I guess that makes us to believe that Germans wash hands because of Mein Kampf.

here's your cause-and-effect.

Where?

Simple enough?

Yes. Very simple.

I guess we had quite a long and interesting discussion but probably one must know when to stop. So I wish you a pleasant time of the day and bid farewell.

P.S.

Jewish war profiteers make money while Germans die of poison gas in trenches of WWI. Certain German soldier nearly dies, goes blind, but recovers. He is angry. What he is observing makes him change his world view and become an activist. ... something ... something ... Genocide!

And here we see that it was actually the Jews themselves who caused the genocide of Jews in Europe. How about such causal link? It has much more weight to it than claiming that the stupid little book did it. End even if we assume that you are right and it caused the genocide, then this fits into the " ... something ... something ... " part and it still is the Jews eventually doing it to themselves.

0
0

[–] the_sovereign ago 

Yeah I see it's pointless arguing with a Holocaust denier and a Nazi sympathizer. If you really can't see the difference between the cause and effect of Germans riding bicycles and Germans reading a book literally calling for the gassing of Jewish people, then I honestly don't know what else to say. Just because some Jewish people may have profited off WW1 does not in anyway shape or form justify the atrocities that the Nazis committed. Atrocities that were confirmed by all sides including the Nazis themselves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust_denial#Examination_of_claims