You can login if you already have an account or register by clicking the button below.
Registering is free and all you need is a username and password. We never ask you for your e-mail.
Well yeah, logically how else would it know that you've said it's name? It has to listen literally all the time, and anyone who thinks they are recording only after it gets a command is delusional. It doesn't have some manual switch that can be turned off; it's always collecting data.
Your words are all stored at some point, because Amazon has to store them to do analytics on and improve their recognition and algorithms. They can't know if a certain phrase or set of words is relevant to improving their algorithms without first storing it. The only question is when/whether or not they delete them.
[+]phoenix8830 points0 points0 points
ago
(edited ago)
[–]phoenix8830 points
0 points
0 points
(+0|-0)
ago
(edited ago)
Listening is processing. A computer can only process by storing data and then operating on it. It could delete the data later, but this is an optional step. Amazon rarely deletes anything, and since the recordings contain the trigger word, we must assume it is continuously recording or the activation command couldn't be part of the output.
Of course they are recording, no data will go to waste. Even if they are 'just' listening, it's not ok. It would be like saying there is nothing wrong with a newly elected Tyrant, because so far he hasn't killed anyone.
You have to think a step ahead and not be gullible and accept every step to total oppression as benign until it's too late.
The first step to a killing field will always be a harmless step.
view the rest of the comments →
[–] CameraCode0 1 point 20 points 21 points (+21|-1) ago
Well yeah, logically how else would it know that you've said it's name? It has to listen literally all the time, and anyone who thinks they are recording only after it gets a command is delusional. It doesn't have some manual switch that can be turned off; it's always collecting data.
[–] jqueso 4 points 2 points 6 points (+6|-4) ago
Listening isn't the same as recording and storing.
[–] Notimportant36 0 points 7 points 7 points (+7|-0) ago
You can get your records, both Alexa and Google save these files on open internet, not encrypted.
When you say the "hi alexa" the recording of your commands INCLUDES the "hi alexa".
[–] CameraCode0 0 points 2 points 2 points (+2|-0) ago
Your words are all stored at some point, because Amazon has to store them to do analytics on and improve their recognition and algorithms. They can't know if a certain phrase or set of words is relevant to improving their algorithms without first storing it. The only question is when/whether or not they delete them.
[–] phoenix883 ago (edited ago)
Listening is processing. A computer can only process by storing data and then operating on it. It could delete the data later, but this is an optional step. Amazon rarely deletes anything, and since the recordings contain the trigger word, we must assume it is continuously recording or the activation command couldn't be part of the output.
[–] Cold_Guinea_Pig ago
Of course they are recording, no data will go to waste. Even if they are 'just' listening, it's not ok. It would be like saying there is nothing wrong with a newly elected Tyrant, because so far he hasn't killed anyone. You have to think a step ahead and not be gullible and accept every step to total oppression as benign until it's too late.
The first step to a killing field will always be a harmless step.