You can login if you already have an account or register by clicking the button below.
Registering is free and all you need is a username and password. We never ask you for your e-mail.
[–]internet_nomad0 points
0 points
0 points
(+0|-0)
ago
(edited ago)
When thinking about it, I realize how much harder it is to implement in practice than it is to think about in theory. Whether there is an actual stop in play or not / advantage played and so on. Would teams allow for referees to reverse decisions during half time? award or take away a goal that was offside or for some other reason not allowed or allowed? its a hard one to think about, but the referees definetly need to find a solution to their awfulness this seasons.
It would need testing. It's somewhat as easy in practice as well. Rugby already did most of the testing for us. I think most players would be against a reversed call. You could go into the changing rooms in high moral, only to get back into the tunnel and find out that the other team have been awarded a penalty.
Decisions that need milliseconds to be made would be the hardest ones to implement because I wouldn't know how best to implement it.
I think most players would be against a reversed call. You could go into the changing rooms in high moral, only to get back into the tunnel and find out that the other team have been awarded a penalty.
Wouldn't it equal out the gut wrenching feeling that the opposition had to feel when they were on the wrong end of a call, an offisde goal / penalty/ or even red card?
Not sure I would like to see it introduced but if anything shows true fairness then I guess this could be it.
view the rest of the comments →
[–] internet_nomad ago (edited ago)
When thinking about it, I realize how much harder it is to implement in practice than it is to think about in theory. Whether there is an actual stop in play or not / advantage played and so on. Would teams allow for referees to reverse decisions during half time? award or take away a goal that was offside or for some other reason not allowed or allowed? its a hard one to think about, but the referees definetly need to find a solution to their awfulness this seasons.
[–] VernacularOracle ago
It would need testing. It's somewhat as easy in practice as well. Rugby already did most of the testing for us. I think most players would be against a reversed call. You could go into the changing rooms in high moral, only to get back into the tunnel and find out that the other team have been awarded a penalty.
Decisions that need milliseconds to be made would be the hardest ones to implement because I wouldn't know how best to implement it.
[–] internet_nomad ago
Thinking about something.
Wouldn't it equal out the gut wrenching feeling that the opposition had to feel when they were on the wrong end of a call, an offisde goal / penalty/ or even red card?
Not sure I would like to see it introduced but if anything shows true fairness then I guess this could be it.