You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

1
2

[–] Brashmonkey 1 point 2 points (+3|-1) ago 

Plus the kinds of things the Geneva convention forbids are the sort of things that if left unchecked can lead to serious long term hatred, which leads to reoccurring conflict that only builds

0
1

[–] ShinyVoater 0 points 1 point (+1|-0) ago 

The ideas behind the Geneva conventions were created under a lens shaped by a millennium of war between states being armed disputes between kings, but after World War II, it's nigh-impossible for most of us to see war without some deep moral dimension. Extending protections to the armies of opposing lords is a simple cost-benefit analysis when it means getting those same benefits for your own in a war over who gets the oaken bucket this year, but when war starts to take on a "we're good, they're evil" tone 100% of the time, it becomes harder and harder to justify holding back against the demons.

0
0

[–] akuta ago 

but when war starts to take on a "we're good, they're evil" tone 100% of the time, it becomes harder and harder to justify holding back against the demons.

Which is precisely the point that the media plays in this whole issue over the last 60 years. War has been glorified and the "enemies" are always "the bad guys."

1
1

[–] AlphaWookie 1 point 1 point (+2|-1) ago 

Really the tribes wiped away by Genghis Khan will never ever get a chance to make war again. The Native Americans will never wage war again against the US, the land is now secure. None of the tribes that resisted the Islamic expansion in the Middle east will never make war again. The Carthaginians will never make war again. Can you name any of the tribes that the Egyptian Empire crushed? Even for its sort period of time Alexander the Great secured Europe and spread civilization through much of the near east and secured a future for Greece into modernity. Overwhelming aggression against your enemy means they can never make war again. History is filled with thousands of tribes and kingdoms that will never be remembered who's names are unknown only the Empires that crushed and secured there peace through violence survived for any amount of time and influenced world history.