You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

4
-4

[–] Joe_McCarthy 4 points -4 points (+0|-4) ago 

I don't think you know much about Marx. In substance his ideas were influenced by English political economy and German and ancient Greek philosophy. He was a Jew only by ancestry. This is not irrelevant of course but his father was basically irreligious - and an irreligious Lutheran convert at that who converted around the time of Marx's birth. Marx was not raised as a religious Jew and was even apparently baptized Lutheran. He was arguably even anti-Semitic himself.

http://www.vho.org/GB/Journals/JHR/5/1/Whisker69-76.html

This is yet again indicative of why the endless jewbad around here is bullshit. I just linked to a Holocaust denial site but you people have only the most superficial grasp of the Jewish question. It's just shoddy argumentation, inaccurate details, and conspiracy spam.

0
1

[–] Adrianmc 0 points 1 point (+1|-0) ago 

Yeah just a massive cohensidence that Marx's grand parents were Talmudic Jews like Freuds, and that his (((totally not Jewish))) ideas from the mid 19th C just happen to dove tail with the ideas for world domination and enslavement as set out in the contemporaneous Protocols of Zion. The fact that it's the perfect ideological tool for undermining nation states and destroying national identity is all just a cohensidence. Marx wasn;t in any way of the Jew by blood and his ideas are not in the least perfectly aligned with those of the (((cabal))) and genocidally calamitous for the rest of us.

0
0

[–] 16472927? ago 

He's still a Jew by ancestry.

You are being fooled by the shifting nature of Jewish identity. If being an atheist was a way out of Jewishness, you'd have to toss half the US Jewish population.

You have precisely zero knowledge of what his father actually believed. Many Jews converted to Christianity in order to further their own financial aims, in order to infiltrate the churches.

Anyone can get a bit of water sprinkled on their head and go to church. I suggest you read the history of the conversos/marranos.

0
0

[–] Joe_McCarthy ago  (edited ago)

I know a good bit about what his father believed. He was an irreligious liberal Prussian patriot who converted to Lutheranism to get law clients.

The larger point though is that there is no reason to assume what OP is contending. It is conspiracy spam speculation. What is known about Marx suggests different sources by which he came by his theories. Communism isn't some kind of Judaism. It is a theory borne of the excesses of the industrial revolution applying the theories of Hegel. To the extent it is Jewish at all one need look to Ricardo rather than the Talmud. Marx's Jewishness is not irrelevant, even in his cultural background, but there's little reason to look there other than to indulge in yet more jewbad conspiracy spam. This OP narrative makes far less sense than what is public record about Marx's bio and which I've outlined. Your talking of conversos is also even more speculative as applied to Marx.