You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

5
6

[–] zoetry 5 points 6 points (+11|-5) ago 

At -274 [She] is unable to perform her duties as a mod

That's not true.There's no rule that even suggests that a moderator must comment. Personally, I've always hated that moderators feel compelled to comment to leave a reason for deleting a submission. It gives them an inappropriate opportunity for positive karma. Removing or stifling conversations does not, by any means, contribute to the conversation.

At any rate, there's nothing stopping her from having another mod leave a deletion notice, or, as far as I'm aware, PMing a user with a reason for deletion.

If they implemented deletion reasons as they should, she'd have even less 'need' to comment.

and she will never climb above -50 ever again

Says you. Maybe some other people agree. It is, at best, a guess. Amalek's gotten himself out of some ridiculous holes before.

She fell below -50 hours after the transfer was granted. The transfer should have been annulled at that time, anyway. Transfer rules explicitly forbid transferring moderatorship to such a universally-hated user.

The rules are not retroactive. Where'd you get that idea?

She met both the original and updated rules at time of request, and at time of transfer. That's all that currently matters for /v/subverserequest.

8
-2

[–] frankenmine [S] 8 points -2 points (+6|-8) ago  (edited ago)

This isn't about posting or commenting (though those are also factors). Falling below -50 shuts off certain mod tools, as well. That's the biggest factor.

That's why being above -50 is specifically a condition of a head mod transfer.

She's fallen afoul of that condition mere hours after the transfer, so the transfer should be annulled, and she should preferably be demodded completely.

The community simply doesn't want her.

5
2

[–] zoetry 5 points 2 points (+7|-5) ago 

She's fallen afoul of that condition mere hours after the transfer, so the transfer should be annulled, and she should preferably be demodded completely.

So you should be asking for a rule change, not an unfounded demodding.

The community simply doesn't want her.

Some people certainly don't. She's only fallen, what ~3,000 points? And you think that's enough, given that there are tons of sock puppets and people that will have gone way back in She's history downvoting things that had no place being downvoted, to represent a community with almost 47,000 people in it? Really?

If only the 11 people that upvoted this post went in with 2-3 alt accounts, they could easily have caused as large of a shift as has happened recently.

Where's your evidence that a significant proportion of the community doesn't want her? I've certainly seen some hate here and there, and she's certainly been brigaded by maybe a couple dozen people, but it seems to be a tiny majority of the community that A.) cares enough, and B.) Is on your side.