You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

0
2

[–] johnparish 0 points 2 points (+2|-0) ago 

My issue is that when a sub doesn't play by any sort of rules, why should it get any shine from /v/all?

If you need 15000 CCP to downvote, you are now playing on an unever playing field, same with not having a downvote button. Why should this actions be rewarded with a higher place on /all? It is all about /all being a fair front page, and it wouldn't be with these subs not allowing downvotes.

0
0

[–] ShitHouse ago 

Maybe a points requirement for downvoating or banning downvoating is a bad idea. When i click all, i want to see content from all subverses.

0
0

[–] johnparish ago 

I am with you but /all would just be focusing on subs that have those rules.

I would be okay with getting rid of both the points requirement and removing the downvote button hiding. I think that would be ideal.

0
0

[–] w00dy [S] ago 

/all /isn't/ the frontpage though. /all is (or should be, I guess) /all.

I'm a huge advocate of the frontpage being /all, though, but I do like the logic of the suggested restrictions to /all I've been seeing, so perhaps use that for the frontpage and leave /all to be /all!

0
0

[–] johnparish ago 

But we don't have a front page so /v/all kind of becomes that. Still don't think subs should be rewarded for getting rid of downvotes.