You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →


[–] Gigan 1 points 15 points (+16|-1) ago 

That's weird, because it's a term that evolved on its own in the gaming/YouTube culture. Sony didn't have anything to do with its creation.


[–] CobraStallone 0 points 5 points (+5|-0) ago 

a term that evolved on its own in the gaming/YouTube culture

Yeah like, two kids and a ball beat YouTube and gaming by hundreds of years on that one I think.


[–] Gigan 0 points 0 points (+0|-0) ago 

The phrase "let's play" being used as a noun is a new phenomenon.


[–] CaveChicken 2 points -2 points (+0|-2) ago 

The connotation is completely different though. "Let's play" the statement has been around for centuries. "Let's play" the term/genre is a fairly new phenomenon, and to equate those two things would be disingenuous at best and ignorant at worst.


[–] SkepticalMartian 1 points 3 points (+4|-1) ago 

Trademarks are not patents or copyright. You don't have to be the person to coin the phrase in order to trademark it.


[–] Totenglocke 0 points 8 points (+8|-0) ago 

I'm going to trademark the words play, box, station, the letter x, and making a logo of a stylized piece of fruit. I'd make a fortune.


[–] Gigan 0 points 3 points (+3|-0) ago 

So I could trademark it?


[–] 3836827? 1 points -1 points (+0|-1) ago  (edited ago)

A potential trademark may be classified as (1) generic, (2) descriptive, (3) suggestive, or (4) arbitrary or fanciful.

A term is generic when it is considered the common name for a product or service in its class. For example, a car is a car, and nobody can trademark the term "car" with respect to a car.

A term is descriptive when it is considered a plainly descriptive name for the product or service. For example, the term "Vision Center" was considered descriptive of a location that dealt primarily with vision related products.

A term is considered suggestive when it suggests, rather than describes, some particular characteristic of the goods or services to which it applies and requires the consumer to exercise the imagination in order to draw a conclusion as to the nature of the goods and services. One example of this is "Coppertone" sun tan lotion -- it suggests the copper tone of skin you'll have after sun tanning.

Finally a term is considered fanciful when it does not have any connection to the product or service in question.

A generic term can never attain trademark protection. Further, a previously trademarked term that becomes generic may lose trademark protection. This occurred with the term "Aspirin" and "Cellophane". They were found to have become generic, and thus trademark protection was cancelled.

A descriptive term generally cannot be protected by trademark protection. They may become valid marks, however, by acquiring a secondary meaning in the minds of the consuming public.

A suggestive term generally can be protected by trademark protection without any requirement to prove a secondary meaning.

A fanciful term is is the easiest to defend, as it has no common meaning relating to the good or service except the one you have prescribed it. One example of this is the term "Kodak" referring to cameras.

In this case, "Let's Play" is a generic term referring to the entire product category of streaming video. Sony did not create the term, it is not currently a leader in the term. There are presently 15 million videos on youtube with the term "Let's Play" in the title.

Sony is clearly in the wrong, and should not have been granted the trademark to the phrase "Let's Play" relating to streaming video.