You can login if you already have an account or register by clicking the button below.
Registering is free and all you need is a username and password. We never ask you for your e-mail.
[+]Clubtalk0 points1 point1 point
ago
(edited ago)
[–]Clubtalk0 points
1 point
1 point
(+1|-0)
ago
(edited ago)
Good question
" ... we don't experience the process of an idea forming ..." if you get ideas or ideas happen to you, as you put it, then you do experience it.
Your question depends on how you would view/answer it. In relation to computer programs, maybe you could view it as some ... some kind of "random" result, maybe ... Computer programs do not have or experience ideas... Guess in the context of code some deep neural nets could experience some kind of rapid advance at some points - this do have some resemblance to idea forming. Not just that some simple algorithm quickly learns, which many do, but then more training have diminishing return. Maybe some inputs that crosses the network or brain in some more or less "random" routes or just keeps the signal all the way through connections or synapses...
I am very deterministic but ideas or what we perceive as some kind of "random impulses" are hard to explain. we still could . I still keep thinking they must come from somewhere.
I think the question is how do one create the phenomenon of an idea either in some kind artificial intelligence or an computer or animals or artificially created being?
humans can write different code or do stuff in a different way, algorithms do not write a new program by themselves?
view the rest of the comments →
[–] Clubtalk 0 points 1 point 1 point (+1|-0) ago (edited ago)
Good question
" ... we don't experience the process of an idea forming ..." if you get ideas or ideas happen to you, as you put it, then you do experience it.
Your question depends on how you would view/answer it. In relation to computer programs, maybe you could view it as some ... some kind of "random" result, maybe ... Computer programs do not have or experience ideas... Guess in the context of code some deep neural nets could experience some kind of rapid advance at some points - this do have some resemblance to idea forming. Not just that some simple algorithm quickly learns, which many do, but then more training have diminishing return. Maybe some inputs that crosses the network or brain in some more or less "random" routes or just keeps the signal all the way through connections or synapses...
I am very deterministic but ideas or what we perceive as some kind of "random impulses" are hard to explain. we still could . I still keep thinking they must come from somewhere.
I think the question is how do one create the phenomenon of an idea either in some kind artificial intelligence or an computer or animals or artificially created being?
humans can write different code or do stuff in a different way, algorithms do not write a new program by themselves?
[–] Othmar_Regin [S] 0 points 1 point 1 point (+1|-0) ago
If AI can't form ideas(outside it's context) than it's not truly intelligent