Archived Is Bill Maher a Jew or an Irish reprobate Catholic? (ethnicelebs.com)
submitted ago by Joe_McCarthy
Posted by: Joe_McCarthy
Posting time: 1.1 years ago on
Last edit time: never edited.
Archived on: 1/12/2020 10:00:00 AM
Views: 23
SCP: -3
5 upvotes, 8 downvotes (38% upvoted it)
Archived Is Bill Maher a Jew or an Irish reprobate Catholic? (ethnicelebs.com)
submitted ago by Joe_McCarthy
view the rest of the comments →
[–] Joe_McCarthy [S] 3 points -2 points 1 point (+1|-3) ago
I say he's a mick. And a very bad or former Catholic. Certainly no indication he has ever practiced Judaism.
[–] KosherHiveKicker 0 points 3 points 3 points (+3|-0) ago (edited ago)
You are fucking delusional, and an idiot for attempting to push the lie that an ethnic, Atheist Jew has "practice Judaism" to be Jewish.
[–] Joe_McCarthy [S] 2 points -1 points 1 point (+1|-2) ago
His upbringing and cultural background are plainly more Irish and Catholic than Jewish. Just calling him a Jew does not help your argument. Clearly we have a case of hybrid identity on some level and he is not wholly one thing or the other. But you speak as if he is Jared Kushner. He wouldn't be even if he identified as Jewish - and it isn't clear to me he does. His self-identification would certainly be a better indicator than your anti-Semitism though.