You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

0
0

[–] 9-11 ago 

Later experiments in quantum physics have shown a void can experience local fluctuation in energy

conveniently already with an x,y,z space existing and time ticking away already. The experiments you speak of showing the quantum fluxuations are only possible for brief instants under specific conditions and have demonstrably shown that the larger the mass the briefer the existence, not the other way around. This essentially destroys the entire theory that you seem to be taking on "faith alone".

equations of thermo and expansion of the universe

you cannot use empirically derived formulas to prove anything. I'm not anti-science, i tend to think the evidence of the CBR does in fact show the early expansion of the universe, but you are specifically talking about the "time" before the big bang when time literally didnt exist, not to mention matter, or the xyz plane of space.

0
0

[–] Frenchgeek ago 

This essentially destroys the entire theory that you seem to be taking on "faith alone".

http://gizmodo.com/astronomers-discover-first-direct-proof-of-the-big-bang-1545525927
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_fluctuation
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilkinson_Microwave_Anisotropy_Probe

And the origin point is not a prerequisite for the theory to work, it is merely a mundane way to explain the mathematics of it, and the mathematics are derived from what we see of the Universe today, what we should expect to find left of the younger Universe and we keep finding evidence predicted by the theory.

You cannot use empirically derived formulas to prove anything.

Congratulations, you just decided physics was wrong.

0
0

[–] 9-11 ago  (edited ago)

It seems you ignored my entire post. Quantum fluxuations are only shown in a laboratory setting, not the vacuum of space, and have the existence of space and time already. This cannot be correlated to a non-describable void where space, time, matter do not exist. period. You seem to have several misconceptions about quantum fluxuations and have a weird desire to plug the gaps in your own creation story with them.

Congratulations, you just decided physics was wrong.

It has application. Only for the understood physical phenomenon it is being used to desribe. To extrapolate that to unobservable points in space and time isn't science. And you are right, I did kind of just disprove most of cosmology and string theory, literally a bum on the street could disprove these entire fields of physics.