I mean, yeah, they allow you to say, "I disagree with this", and voice your opinion as an opposite to "I agree", but on the other hand they come with a lot of negatives.
- They encourage group-think
- Discourages controversial opinions from being posted
- Discourages commenting in general
- Controversial opinions are buried/hidden
I'm not saying disable downvotes because someone's fee fees would get hurt, I'm suggesting to just let "shitty comments" (or so the community thinks) stay at 0 or positive (but with a low score relative to the good comments). The good comments would still technically rise to the top.
Downvoting in general is a shitty way to disagree anyway, because if you don't explain why you're disagreeing it's sort of useless. The only time they're really worth something is for spam posts, but they can just be reported, no?
Thoughts?
view the rest of the comments →
[–] BrazilianRider ago
I dunno how it'd work, but I'd like to see a system where you have to give a short explanation to each downvote. Then if you clicked on a link under the comment, you could see all the "reviews" (anonymously, of course) and the ones that were illegitimately downvoted could be flagged so the mods can investigate.
[–] spryes [S] ago
That's really interesting, I actually like that.