You are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the comments →

0
0

[–] 17526635? ago 

Oh? And who created it?

Congress of Vienna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congress_of_Vienna

Do Austrians not share the same language, culture, and customs as the rest of Germany?

no. they share some same language, culture, and customs as some people living in germany. not all. and i am not talking about recent immigrants also..just to be clear. there are considerable differences

0
0

[–] 17527899? ago 

>>12990291

germany is relatively recent state in today's boarders

As I said before, it is a nation. A state composed of one people. The German nation existed long before the state and despite your claims, the Germans of Austria and the Germans of the rest of Germany are indeed one people with a common culture, history, and blood.

0
0

[–] 17527912? ago 

As I said before, it is a nation.

it is not.

A state composed of one people.

it is not

The German nation existed long before the state

it did not

and despite your claims, the Germans of Austria and the Germans of the rest of Germany are indeed one people with a common culture, history, and blood.

you are wrong. just look at the language

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bavarian_language

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alemannic_German

and then you have standard german. which is created langue and not dialect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_German

germans do not exist as cohesive group of people. prove me wrong

0
0

[–] 17526653? ago 

Oh? And who created it?

Congress of Vienna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congress_of_Vienna

Germany existed long before.

The Frankish empire was whole German, not just Germanic at around AD400. It were German warriors subduing former Roman colonies and not the reverse.

Even if one consider the split of the Frankish empire as foundation of Germany (and France) then would that have been in AD834, treaty of Verdun, still the oldest state in Europe.

Do Austrians not share the same language, culture, and customs as the rest of Germany?

no. they share some same language, culture, and customs as some people living in germany.

You are pig ignorant for ideological reasons.

The dukes of Austria were kings and emperors of Germany for nearly 500 years and of course was Austria part of Germany, still is.

Just because the enemies of Germany want to partition Germany doesn’t that make that the Austrians less German.

0
0

[–] 17527896? ago 

Germany existed long before.

not in current borders.

The Frankish empire was whole German, not just Germanic at around AD400. It were German warriors subduing former Roman colonies and not the reverse.

"German warriors" do not exist. there are different tribes that could be considered german. here is a list.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ancient_Germanic_peoples_and_tribes

as you can see there are anglo-saxons, galic tribes even vikings. germans as uniform genetics does not exist. it is conglomerate of different genetics

Even if one consider the split of the Frankish empire as foundation of Germany (and France) then would that have been in AD834, treaty of Verdun, still the oldest state in Europe.

greece would be oldest state in europe. then italy. german tribes did not have a runing water in the time when rome had cloaca maxima ( sewage system)

>>12990402

The dukes of Austria were kings and emperors of Germany for nearly 500 years and of course was Austria part of Germany, still is.

yes, they were. but germany had very different borders at that time.

Just because the enemies of Germany want to partition Germany doesn’t that make that the Austrians less German.

no, you got me all wrong. i do not think austrians are less german. i think germans are not enough austrian. germans are cross breed. austrians are pure bread. after all, hitler was austrian. you did not know that ? that hitler did not think that germans are pure aryan blood ?