[–] boater 0 points 2 points 2 points (+2|-0) ago (edited ago)
If I post a spoiler to the Game of Thrones sub without a spoiler tag - it shouldn't be upvoated.
What if the thread is only 1 hour old and there are only 2 comments, and one of them is a spoiler? If no one ever read a comments with 0 upvoats, then there would never be comments with more than 0 upvoats. If several people are reading the thread and currently formulating a reply in an effort to create comments worth at least 1 upvoat, they should still be able to enforce the subverse specific rule of no spoilers and downvoat the spoiler comment in the meantime so that others looking for good comments do not view it by default.
An important part of creating a good signal to noise ratio is hiding and reducing the noise, not simply increasing the volume of the signal in an effort to compete with low quality spam.
I like the idea in theory, but what's to stop me from just selecting anything regardless of whether or not it applies?
Laziness, culture, and education. Laziness in the sense that you no longer have access to one-click downvoting, you have to perform at least 3 clicks and do some reading. Culture in the sense that this functionality would serve as a constant declaration to every user that the intended purpose of downvote is to enforce objective rule violations and is not a disagree button. Education in the sense that every time you try to downvote, you are forced to read and parse the subverse sidebar rules and be subconciously indoctrinated into being a model citizen of that subverse.
This will of course not prevent a determined individual from subjectively downvoting, it will simply decrease the likelihood of unwanted downvoting, by promoting the notion of good or objective downvoting in its place.
[–] UlteriorMotives 0 points 1 point 1 point (+1|-0) ago
Alright. I'm convinced. It seems like it could potentially solve the "problem" of downvoats by making it more difficult to just downvoat for the heck of it while still allowing the downvoat to do its job of moderating content faster and more effectively than a mere lack of upvoats.