0
2

[–] mmmmdonuts 0 points 2 points (+2|-0) ago 

Just my take, I guess, but I'm the same size and weight. I'm a social eater, so people tend to think I eat a lot all the time but really when I'm by myself I can't really be bothered to eat that much at all. Or, she just thinks she eats a lot compared to her family or culture and has no idea how much fat people really eat...

0
2

[–] shart_in_a_fat_roll 0 points 2 points (+2|-0) ago 

Obviously she has a higher TDEE

Not obvious at all. She hasn't done a count yet, so we have no reason to believe her TDEE is any higher than would be predicted for her height+weight.

I offered this as a counter example

It's not a counter example. Hams use anecdotes like this to support their theory that some people are "naturally thin" and therefore they are "naturally fat."